Wednesday, October 19, 2011

I was here at the beginning! I'm not an Immigrant!

As an undergraduate at Dominican University, my daughter, like me, is taking an Educational Technology class.  We often compare notes.  Recently, before I was assigned to read Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants by Marc Prensky, she referred to me as a Digital Immigrant.  I objected, saying that as a Software Engineer and System Administrator throughout the 80s and 90s my experience with technology was as solid as anyone's.  She then explained that because I did not grow up with technology, my brain actually formed differently, so I was still an immigrant.  Intrigued, I read Prensky's article.

I find much in this article fascinating.  However, I still question the validity of the basic premise of a biological difference in the students of the current generation.  I hold that if a time traveler came back to my high school class and brought well planned lessons with interactive videos, multimedia, and other technologies, we too could have learned better from these methods simply because they are better methods than what was available back then.

I spent several years as a system administrator in Mechanical Computer Aided Engineering (MCAE).  Much of my responsibility was to implement training on these systems.  Therefore, I found the concept of a video game to train on MCAE as Prensky developed in The Monkey Wrench Conspiracy to be fascinating.  However, I again dispute the validity of Prensky's statement that digital natives will learn better with this because they have been brought up this way and their brains are wired differently.  I think digital immigrants will learn better with this approach also, simply because it is a better approach.

So the thing that I still have not refuted is Prensky's actual assertion that the brains of today's students are physically different than those of earlier generations.  However, Jamie McKenzie in his article Digital Nativism Digital Delusions and Digital Deprivation does a superb job of this.  He points out that Prensky only cites a single source as evidence.  That source only contains a misspelled name and no actual book or article.  McKenzie's research found that the actual quote used as evidence was referring to traumatic childhood experiences changing a child's brain.  So, if there is no evidence that my brain is different because I did not grow up with technology, I can claim that the differences are just differences in knowledge based on experience.

Let's now look at the terms "native" and "immigrant" in their more common context.  Yes, a person native to the United States is obviously more at home living in a democracy and all that involves than someone who immigrates here.  However, in many cases the immigrant can understand and appreciate what citizenship involves much more than the native.  I think this can be said for the digital analogy also.  Furthermore, there is another category being completely overlooked here.  The people who really understood what democracy meant and had the vision to see its massive potential were the people who defined our nation as it was formed, our founding fathers.  People like Steve Jobs and Bill Gates are not digital immigrants.  They are digital founding fathers.  Even the everyday people of the revolutionary times, the colonists, had a deeper understanding and grander vision of where the country could go than the generations that were later born here.  Likewise,  the people working in technology as the revolution began in the 1980s probably had and still have a better vision of where technology can take us, than those raised with it all around them.

I am a digital colonist!

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

PowerPoint: The Good, the Bad, and the Really Ugly

Several years ago, I delivered a presentation at a conference for users of  mechanical computer aided engineering (MCAE) software.  I gave the presentation using the Microsoft PowerPoint application.  However, in the program for the conference, my presentation and those of others were not listed as presentations, but rather as papers.  This designation illustrates that the work and research behind the presentation was what was important, rather than the PowerPoint file itself.  Often times the item laying behind a presentation at a conference such as this one actually is a published paper.  In my case, the work was two years of research and design developing a unique way to model a library of fasteners-- i.e., nuts, bolts, rivets, etc.

The idea of the importance of the work behind a presentation, specifically in an educational environment, is the crux of Scoring Power Points  by Jamie McKenzie for the online journal From Now On.  In his article, McKenzie warns that when the only deliverable from a student project is a PowerPoint presentation, the slide/bullet point nature of PowerPoint can lead to a presentation which lacks direction or a clear logical thought process.  Students can easily be led into creating simple bullet points with no hierarchical order or logical flow.  Furthermore, students put more effort into designing the presentation than into the actual work, which results in a show which is heavy on inappropriate slide transition animations, sound effects, and other sensory assaults that he refers to as flash.  To describe this phenomenon, McKenzie has coined the term PowerPointlessness.

To avoid PowerPointlessness, he suggest that all student projects which are to be presented to a group using PowerPoint, should actually have three deliverable items.
  1. An actual research paper in the form of an essay, which presents the topic in a logical manner.  This paper actually should be able to stand alone.
  2. A well designed PowerPoint presentation which condenses the paper to an outline.
  3. Presentation of the paper to the class, using Powerpoint, but now orally expanding the outline to cover all the flow and logic in the paper itself.
The expectations for each of these steps must be provided by the teacher in the form of rubrics.  Furthermore, I would suggest that each step be reviewed with the student before the next step is undertaken.

I have personally seen many of the pitfalls described by McKenzie in the designs of  PowerPoint presentations.  The most common have to do with just an extreme amount of flash.  If something does not help to emphasize a point, it really should not be in the presentation.   The other pitfalls all have to do with the amount and organization of the actual information on a slide.  To avoid any copyright or personal repercussions from the authors of slides that I would criticize , I will only use one of my slides as an example.  This slide is an example of a poor design.

It breaks two of the rules presented by McKenzie.  First it is two wordy and would probably just end up being read by the presenter.  Furthermore, the text which is from a report published by the National Institute on Safety and Health (NIOSH) on Workplace Use of Back Belts, is simply cut and pasted from the original, requiring no critical thinking on the part of the presentation's author.

The same information is better presented on this slide that I use in a safety lesson on ergonomics in which I summarize the findings of the above report.


Finally on this slide, the method of displaying the information is important.  If all the bullets  are brought in at one time, the audience would start to read the slide and not pay attention to the explanations given by the speaker.  On the other hand the five single word sub-bullets are simply a list that does not require individual verbal explanation.  Bringing these in individually would amount to tedium, and should therefore be brought in simultaneously with the third bullet.

My last comment is actually a partial disagreement with McKenzie.  He states that using the recording features of PowerPoint to record voices and simply play the presentation to your audience is unacceptable.  I agree if the audience is a live and present group.  However, recorded presentations can be shared allowing remote users to view your presentation.


Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Thoughts on Technology and Higher Order Thinking Skills

I would like to start this discussion of how technology can develop higher order thinking and problem solving skills by playing somewhat of a semantic game.  The difference between initially learning a skill and later developing it to its full potential must be fully understood.  The Center for Applied Research in Educational Technology (CARET)  states on its website, “Technology can enable the development of higher order thinking skills when students are taught to apply the process of problem solving and are then allowed opportunities to apply technology in development of solutions.”   The key to this statement is that the students learn the process of problem solving first.  Any use of the new skill, with or without the use of technology, will develop it further.  However, the same CARET article cites much research that clearly shows that when technology is used these skills are developed further than when it is not.  I contend this result is due more to the increase in efficiency that technology brings to many of the problem solving activities than from anything actually learned from the technology itself.  More on that later.

In an article written for edutopia.com, Marc Prensky describes four phases of technology integration as
·         Dabbling.
·         Doing old things in old ways.
·         Doing old things in new ways.
·         Doing new things in new ways.
He then points out that most technology used in education is actually in phase two above.  While use of email and word processing programs may seem to be a new way of doing things, we are still basically sending messages and typing papers.  While technology may speed up these processes, they are really the same old methods of doing the job.  We are just starting to enter the third phase of integration with many of the Web 2.0 tools such as wikis and social bookmarking.  The fourth phase is yet to be defined.

Keeping Prensky’s definitions in mind, let’s consider the software examples given in an  Education World  article.  This article uses the six levels of learning as defined by Bloom’s Taxonomy by looking at examples of software which may be used at each phase.  However, even at the highest two levels, synthesis and evaluation, which really represent higher order thinking, the listed web tools do not represent any real new ways of learning.  All the tools cited in this article can be grouped into three categories—research, memorization aids, and data gathering/reporting.

The research tools are all basically some sort of search engine with varying methods to access and organize the information.  The memorization tools range from online flash cards to sites where students can take quizzes on books they have read. Finally, the data gathering and reporting tools include sites for building and performing on line surveys to gather information and charting tools to report the information.  All of these activities can be done, albeit more slowly, without technology.  For example, without technology, a student could look up information from periodicals using the hard copy indices, search the stacks or microfiche records, and find the desired article.  While using online tools to find and print an electronic copy of the article is faster, in the end the student is locating, reading and taking notes on the same material.

As I contended above, it is the speed and efficiency with which a student can perform these tasks that make the real differences we see in higher order thinking skills when technology is used.  Because students can accomplish more in the same time frame with technology than without, they have more opportunities to hone their higher order thinking skills.  Also, because of this speed and efficiency provided by technology, much of the drudgery is taken out of many tasks, allowing students to stay engaged with a project longer and push their thinking to even higher levels.

I would like to close my comments by warning about the possibility that incorrect use of technology can actually hamper the development of higher order thinking skills.  I witnessed a blatant example of this misuse in the middle school attended by my children.  The students at this school all took an eight week mini course in industrial technology where they gained hands on experience in skills like wood working, plumbing, electricity, etc.  When the district decided to “integrate” technology into this program, they did not add topics such as digitally controlled tools or computer automated drafting.  Rather they purchased a set of software modules which students would run on a PC.  Each module had two phases, learning and testing.  The learning phase consisted of an article that the student would read on a computer.  Then the students would complete the module by taking an online test.  Because these articles could just as readily have been printed copies and the tests could have been administered manually, these modules did not represent any integration of technology.  In fact, the removal of all hands on experiences took away any student engagement in the projects on which they were working.  No higher order skills were needed in the new curriculum.