The idea of the importance of the work behind a presentation, specifically in an educational environment, is the crux of Scoring Power Points by Jamie McKenzie for the online journal From Now On. In his article, McKenzie warns that when the only deliverable from a student project is a PowerPoint presentation, the slide/bullet point nature of PowerPoint can lead to a presentation which lacks direction or a clear logical thought process. Students can easily be led into creating simple bullet points with no hierarchical order or logical flow. Furthermore, students put more effort into designing the presentation than into the actual work, which results in a show which is heavy on inappropriate slide transition animations, sound effects, and other sensory assaults that he refers to as flash. To describe this phenomenon, McKenzie has coined the term PowerPointlessness.
To avoid PowerPointlessness, he suggest that all student projects which are to be presented to a group using PowerPoint, should actually have three deliverable items.
- An actual research paper in the form of an essay, which presents the topic in a logical manner. This paper actually should be able to stand alone.
- A well designed PowerPoint presentation which condenses the paper to an outline.
- Presentation of the paper to the class, using Powerpoint, but now orally expanding the outline to cover all the flow and logic in the paper itself.
I have personally seen many of the pitfalls described by McKenzie in the designs of PowerPoint presentations. The most common have to do with just an extreme amount of flash. If something does not help to emphasize a point, it really should not be in the presentation. The other pitfalls all have to do with the amount and organization of the actual information on a slide. To avoid any copyright or personal repercussions from the authors of slides that I would criticize , I will only use one of my slides as an example. This slide is an example of a poor design.
It breaks two of the rules presented by McKenzie. First it is two wordy and would probably just end up being read by the presenter. Furthermore, the text which is from a report published by the National Institute on Safety and Health (NIOSH) on Workplace Use of Back Belts, is simply cut and pasted from the original, requiring no critical thinking on the part of the presentation's author.
The same information is better presented on this slide that I use in a safety lesson on ergonomics in which I summarize the findings of the above report.
Finally on this slide, the method of displaying the information is important. If all the bullets are brought in at one time, the audience would start to read the slide and not pay attention to the explanations given by the speaker. On the other hand the five single word sub-bullets are simply a list that does not require individual verbal explanation. Bringing these in individually would amount to tedium, and should therefore be brought in simultaneously with the third bullet.
My last comment is actually a partial disagreement with McKenzie. He states that using the recording features of PowerPoint to record voices and simply play the presentation to your audience is unacceptable. I agree if the audience is a live and present group. However, recorded presentations can be shared allowing remote users to view your presentation.


I like the self-reflection you did by using your own slides, Jeff. I also like the bad-Jeff, good-Jeff look at powerpoint slides. Applying the concepts to see the difference at work is helpful. Nice work.
ReplyDeleteI liked how you summed up the 3 major points in an easy to read way. The picture examples were great and helped to a visual understanding to the topic. Your personal experiences also added to a deeper understanding. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDelete