I find much in this article fascinating. However, I still question the validity of the basic premise of a biological difference in the students of the current generation. I hold that if a time traveler came back to my high school class and brought well planned lessons with interactive videos, multimedia, and other technologies, we too could have learned better from these methods simply because they are better methods than what was available back then.
I spent several years as a system administrator in Mechanical Computer Aided Engineering (MCAE). Much of my responsibility was to implement training on these systems. Therefore, I found the concept of a video game to train on MCAE as Prensky developed in The Monkey Wrench Conspiracy to be fascinating. However, I again dispute the validity of Prensky's statement that digital natives will learn better with this because they have been brought up this way and their brains are wired differently. I think digital immigrants will learn better with this approach also, simply because it is a better approach.So the thing that I still have not refuted is Prensky's actual assertion that the brains of today's students are physically different than those of earlier generations. However, Jamie McKenzie in his article Digital Nativism Digital Delusions and Digital Deprivation does a superb job of this. He points out that Prensky only cites a single source as evidence. That source only contains a misspelled name and no actual book or article. McKenzie's research found that the actual quote used as evidence was referring to traumatic childhood experiences changing a child's brain. So, if there is no evidence that my brain is different because I did not grow up with technology, I can claim that the differences are just differences in knowledge based on experience.
Let's now look at the terms "native" and "immigrant" in their more common context. Yes, a person native to the United States is obviously more at home living in a democracy and all that involves than someone who immigrates here. However, in many cases the immigrant can understand and appreciate what citizenship involves much more than the native. I think this can be said for the digital analogy also. Furthermore, there is another category being completely overlooked here. The people who really understood what democracy meant and had the vision to see its massive potential were the people who defined our nation as it was formed, our founding fathers. People like Steve Jobs and Bill Gates are not digital immigrants. They are digital founding fathers. Even the everyday people of the revolutionary times, the colonists, had a deeper understanding and grander vision of where the country could go than the generations that were later born here. Likewise, the people working in technology as the revolution began in the 1980s probably had and still have a better vision of where technology can take us, than those raised with it all around them.
I am a digital colonist!
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your blog, Jeff. I agree with your comments on the biology of natives and immigrants. I also liked reframing the subject in terms of American colonialism; that really gives us more room to categorize people like you (and Al Gore, lol).
ReplyDelete